place hero

Play It Again Sports - Castle Rock

Supplier of new & used sporting goods

  • Kerbside pickup
  • In-store shopping
740 Wilcox St, Castle Rock, CO, 80104, United States
Closed 路 Opens at 10 AM Thu


10 AM - 7:30 PM
10 AM - 7:30 PM
10 AM - 7:30 PM
9 AM - 6 PM
11 AM - 5 PM
10 AM - 7:30 PM
10 AM - 7:30 PM


63 reviews


"They were extremely helpful and the quality and selection were good."

"It is worth driving a bit farther to check this location out."

"Helpful employees, friendly service."

Morgan Miller10 months ago

Dropped in today 8/5 at noon to grab a longboard, I鈥檝e been putting off for months. The dudes let me try a couple boards out in the parking lot, and even knocked $10 off final coat! Y鈥檃ll made my day, thank you for your kindness 馃槑

Owner's response10 months ago

Thanks for the review Morgan! I'm so glad you found the right longboard for you, have fun with it! We hope to see you again soon.

Vic Lavigne1 year ago

Always a great selection and great prices! I've been here multiple times for baseball gloves, cleats, golf equipment, etc. and they're always polite and helpful!! Will certainly be going back again soon!

Christina Garlockalmost 2 years ago

Amazing! Hillary and her staff are super helpful. Great prices and amazing inventory, went in to say hi and see what was what, will be going back to check out that row machine a bit more seriously!

Owner's responsealmost 2 years ago

Thanks so much for stopping in Chris, it was great to meet you. We appreciate the 5 star review! Hopefully we will see you soon, and don't forget to bring in your gently used equipment so we can pay you cash or store credit on the spot.

Justin Parfreyalmost 2 years ago

Went in for fast pitch softball gear. The "experts" sold me on a 100 dollar used bat. Once I got home I realized the bat was a baseball bat, and can not be used. The gentlemen who sold the bat was very friendly when we bought the bat (but I was told after he is a foot ball expert by the assistant manager). Upon trying to EXCHANGE the bat (still had all tags on) they told me they can only give me 20 dollars without a receipt. The guy who sold me the bat 6 days ago was standing right there verifying he sold me the bat, and the assistant manager wouldn't budge at all. I then tried returning everything (brand new glove, cleats, batting gloves, and the bat) all bought within 6 days and they said it is now used and offered me 50 dollars for stuff they charged me over 200 dollars for. In the end, I drove home and got the receipt and returned everything (over 200 dollars). They seemed to not care that they lost a customer, but at their prices you might as well buy new and actually have a return policy that will protect your purchase.

Lindsay Graymore than 10 months ago

Always super helpful and super informative every time we visit.

Owner's response10 months ago

Thank you for the kind words Lindsay! We hope to see you again soon!

Laura Pricealmost 4 years ago

I spoke with two different employees here today and they were AWESOME!!!!! They were extremely helpful and beyond nice. I needed a white football helmet, a specific size, with a black face mask and they went out of their way to get me exactly what I needed and had it ready for me when I arrived as they knew I was on a time crunch. I will ALWAYS shop here for sports gear for my son!!! They made my life so easy after stressing for two weeks about the helmet!! Thanks guys!!

Owner's responsealmost 4 years ago

Thanks for the nice review Laura! I'm so glad the football helmet worked and you were able to get some credit to put towards your purchase by selling us your other helmet. We look forward to working with you again!

Eric heimalmost 4 years ago

I have visited this location twice this week, the first time a young employee was polite and helpful with a helmet purchase. The second time the owner helped my son in getting properly sized with shoulder pads, football pants and shoes and was respectful of our time as we were in a pinch. I definitely recommend this location!

Owner's responsealmost 4 years ago

Thank you for the kind words Eric! I鈥檓 glad we were able to get your son set up with the equipment he needs for the season. We look forward to seeing you again.

Willie Isomalmost 3 years ago

They were closed for a staff emergency for a few hours when I went to go check for an item in store. I received a response from their social media account and was given an explanation for the closure. Great customer service. Hard to find responsive, caring businesses these days.

Kristin Keesenalmost 7 years ago

The staff here is top notch. I went in with my son and a list of lacrosse items he needed and they outfitted him head to toe, making sure every piece fit and felt comfortable. A few weeks later when we had to return a stick with a cracked cage, they were very accommodating and made sure we left with the best stick they could find! We'll always shop here and recommend to others. Shout out to Elijah for his stellar customer service skills!

Tammy Bangs6 years ago

Bought a board, boots and a new helmet for my 8 yo shredder today, all for under $100! It is an awesome place! Super great customer service by friendly guys who know what they are doing. We will def be back! Highly recommend!



Sporting goods chain that buys, sells & trades a wide variety of equipment, both new & secondhand.

From the business

Identifies as women-owned

Service options

Kerbside pickup
In-store pick-up
In-store shopping


Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance


LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safe space


Quick visit


Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards


Other nearby sporting goods stores that people also search for!

place hero0.16 miles
Elite Sports
Sporting goods store, Embroidery shop, Screen printing shop
place hero1.95 miles
Walmart Supercenter
Department store, Bakery, Clothing store, Electronics store, Furniture store, Grocery store, Hardware store, Home goods store, Sporting goods store, Toy store$
place hero2.32 miles
Murdoch's Ranch & Home Supply
Department store, Clothing store, Hardware store, Sporting goods store
place hero2.56 miles
Big 5 Sporting Goods
Sporting goods store, Camping store, Clothing store, Outdoor sports store, Running store, Shoe store, Sportswear store
place hero2.66 miles
Fanzz Sports Apparel - Castlerock
Sporting goods store, Custom t-shirt store, Department store, Hat shop, Men's clothing store, Sports memorabilia store, Sportswear store, T-shirt store, Women's clothing store